研究生吧 关注:477,732贴子:7,331,968
  • 2回复贴,共1

各位研究生帮我分析一下

取消只看楼主收藏回复

我投了个sci,编辑给了返修,其中一个审稿人就只给了这么个意见,是拒稿的意思吗,如果要拒为什么还要给返修
The manuscript addresses a relevant and scientifically valuable topic in Geotechnics, but there are some major concerns on the methodology and results that prevents to endorse its acceptance at the present stage. Further improvement is needed before being published.


IP属地:广西来自Android客户端1楼2024-01-04 22:14回复
    后续:在除夕那天,编辑又给了二修,两个审稿人同意发表,就剩这个要拒搞的审稿人给了我20条意见,就给了半个月修改,我感觉大部分都是挑刺,无从回答。大过年的


    IP属地:广西来自Android客户端39楼2024-02-12 18:29
    回复
      后后续:修了3次,今天出录用了,感谢解答我的各位老哥,祝各位都出顶刊


      IP属地:广西来自Android客户端40楼2024-03-12 16:55
      收起回复