The flashbacks which illustrate Holmes’ explanation of events at the Falls show the whole truth this time. We see the death of Moriarty and how Holmes watches Watson and the local police searching the area of the struggle. There is a favorite moment for me when Holmes is tempted to shout to his friend but stifles the impulse and makes his escape into three years of oblivion. These scenes are a combination of material shot in Switzerland in 1984 and in North Wales in 1985, because I could not possibly justify a return to Reichenbach.
Conan Doyle had to turn an awkward corner in this narrative: he had to explain why Holmes confided in his brother Mycroft during his absence but not in his loyal friend. Holmes tells us that he needed an absolutely credible account of this “death” and could not depend on Watson to provide one if he knew the truth. Watson is deeply hurt, and John Hawkesworth has added a couple of lines here which help Holmes to retrieve the situation. “I would have thought that I was as trustworthy as your brother,” says Watson. To which Holmes replies, “Of course you are, Watson, but you have a kinder heart.”
As Holmes describes it, his return to Baker Street is equally emotional, although I guess that Mrs. Hudson had been forewarned. Otherwise the hysterics might have been rather more violent than they are. Mycroft has certainly made sure that the rooms at 221B are unchanged except for the one dramatic touch: the print of the Swiss torrent over the fireplace is now swathed in black crepe.
There is, of course, a dangerous adventure to be undertaken, although Holmes refuses to give his friend any details. Having been kept in the dark for three years, Watson has clearly learned to be philosophical about this irritating habit and happily watches Holmes stretch out for a nap on his examination table.
Watson’s patience is rewarded when the pair start their vigil in the empty house and Holmes explains the plot against his life. Watson is properly amazed by the bust of Holmes in the window opposite, which is lovingly manipulated by Mrs. Hudson. The assassin arrives and with his elaborate air rifle—what a beautiful prop that is—and is subdued in a fierce struggle just before Lestrade comes to arrest him. My only regret in all of this is that Patrick Allen found Moran’s line, “You cunning, cunning devil!” too melodramatic for him to carry off. Consequently we lost that as well as Holmes’ quotation from Twelfth Night.
The final scene is a wordy one but saved by both actors playing it with style and wit. Watson finally dons the fez which is, presumably, a gift from Khartoum brought back by Holmes. The reunion is crowned by Mrs. Hudson arriving with champagne, and she, quite rightly, has the last word, “Once again Mr. Sherlock Holmes is free to devote his life to examining those interesting little problems which the complex life of London so plentifully presents.”
*This refers to Cox’s comments about "The Final Problem": “When we see the fatal fight it is a flashback which Holmes introduces in the note he leaves for Watson. But what we are watching is, of course, a lie, and the usual grammar of film dictates that flashbacks never lie. If you see it, it happened, was the rule until 1950. Then Alfred Hitchcock made a movie called Stage Fright, in which we are shown the murderer’s totally misleading version of events surrounding his crime. I remember that is caused a great to-do; audiences felt cheated and critics were censorious. Many years later Hitchcock admitted to Fran?ois Truffault that he never should have done it, and I cannot think of another example of this break with convention. Until 1985, that is, when we showed what Watson believed to have happened and got away with it.”