生人勿进吧 关注:1,164贴子:11,162

《生人勿进》作者评美版《生人勿进》

只看楼主收藏回复

《生人勿进》作者John Ajvide Lindqvist(同时也是瑞典版《生人勿进》的编剧)在8月份的访谈中,特别推荐We, The Infected论坛(这个论坛是目前最受欢迎的关于《生人勿进》相关话题的英文论坛),并表示曾在上发过帖子。
今天,他在该论坛上谈了他对美版《生人勿进》的看法。
I really enjoyed Let me in.
I had seen clips and trailers beforehand, read some reviews and I was prepared for a good movie. But I liked it even better than I had anticipated.
我非常喜欢美版《生人勿进》。
由于之前看过花絮和预告片,加上读了一些影评,我准备看一部好电影。但影片比我预计的还要好。
I didn´t at all feel that it was a shot-for-shot or even scene-for-scene remake. Sure, some scenes have a huge debt to LTROI and the general tone of the film is similar (if darker), but I feel that LMI has very much its own life.
我不认为美版是原封不动的照搬瑞典版,尽管有些地方和瑞典版相似。美版的整体色调和瑞典版相似,甚至可能要更灰暗些。我认为美版有自己的独特的生命力。
For me it was very intense and emotional, and like LTROI it made me cry a few times. But here´s the thing: not in the same places.
美版对我来说非常紧张、动人,我看瑞典版时哭了好几次,看美版时我也哭了好几次,但具体画面不同。
I think I have been very lucky that Matt Reeves felt such a connection to this story, because if you choose to regard it simply as a remake, it must be quite unique in having a director whose emotional ties to the story is so strong that it´s felt through the whole movie. I thought Kodi was great and I identified completely with Owen. I really liked Chloe too, and the fact that her Abby character is played out differently than Eli is for me just a strength that seperates the two movies from each other.
我觉得非常幸运的是,导演马特.里夫斯对《生人勿进》故事有深厚的感情,没有把本片当作一部翻拍片来对待,而是作为一部影片来对待。我认为柯迪演的很棒,我完全相信他扮演的欧文。我也很喜欢科洛,她演的艾比和瑞典版中的艾丽不同,这是美版与瑞典版最大不同之处。


1楼2010-10-03 14:29回复
    2楼2010-10-03 14:30
    回复
      广告
      立即查看
      楼主不在吗?国内又没的看 郁闷


      4楼2010-10-03 18:23
      回复
        你看过了?Eli更孤僻,艾比更热情?


        6楼2010-10-03 20:26
        回复
          回复:3楼
          最大的不同在于科洛和莉娜截然不同的表演风格。


          7楼2010-10-05 11:52
          回复
            http://moviesblog.mtv.com/2010/10/04/let-me-in-let-the-right-one-in-john-lindqvist-note-matt-reeves/
            今日MTV转载了《生人勿进》原著作者John Ajvide Lindqvist发给美版《生人勿进》导演Matt Reeves的信。作者在信中表达了对瑞典版《生人勿进》和美版《生人勿进》的喜爱,原因是这两部影片各有不同。
            "I might just be the luckiest writer alive. To have not only one, but two excellent versions of my debut novel done for the screen feels unreal," Lindqvist writes. "'Let the Right One In' is a great Swedish movie. 'Let Me In' is a great American movie."
            我可能是健在的作者中最幸运的一位了。能看到两部改编自我的首部小说的优秀影片,这简直不可思议。瑞典版《生人勿进》是一部很棒的瑞典影片,美版《生人勿进》是一部很棒的美国影片。
            He continues: "There are notable similarities, and the spirit of Tomas Alfredson is present. But 'Let Me In' puts the emotional pressure in different places and stands firmly on its own legs. Like the Swedish movie, it made me cry, but not at the same points. 'Let Me In' is a dark and violent love story, a beautiful piece of cinema and a respectful rendering of my novel for which I am grateful. Again."
            两部影片有明显的相似之处,美版保持了瑞典版的灵魂。但美版在不同地方加入情感堆积,使之有独特之处。瑞典版和美版都让我感动落泪,但具体地方不同。美版是一部更灰暗和暴力的爱情故事,一部尊重原著的唯美电影作品。我对此不甚感激。


            8楼2010-10-05 12:28
            回复
              什么时候能看。


              9楼2010-10-06 10:51
              回复
                支持作者!支持美版!


                10楼2011-02-10 22:37
                回复
                  广告
                  立即查看
                  现在3个奖项不过还会增加跨度会到今年年底为止,可喜的是IMDB的投票终于经过将近6个月突破1万了不过分数掉到7.3了。


                  12楼2011-02-12 03:32
                  回复
                    得奖的神马都是浮云...当年的shawshank redemption不是完败于forrest gump吗...


                    13楼2011-02-12 10:42
                    回复
                      在影片中导演用粗鲁的男式声音表现了艾比发怒的情节,对久情人冷漠的表现与男孩的温柔形成巨大反差。


                      14楼2011-02-12 21:25
                      回复
                        回复:5楼
                        5楼精辟


                        16楼2011-03-15 13:57
                        回复
                          原版的Eli是男孩,而美版的Abby是女孩。
                          我想这就是作者指的最大不同吧。


                          17楼2011-03-21 19:08
                          回复