投了一篇MDPI的论文, 两个审稿人回复意见了,直接进入decision状态,感觉不妙。
我感觉Reviewer 2 是行家,直接提问了一两个专业问题, 整体评价不仅专业而且友好,给了个“English language and style are fine/minor spell check required”。
重点是,Reviewer 1, 是个hanhan. 一看就是个外行, 不懂概念,把目标检测和目标跟踪混为一谈,挑不了专业,挑你写作问题。最haha的是这位大佬写的“comments” 里面一大堆写作错误(笑喷ing)。 最后给了我一个“I consider the paper acceptable after minor revision of the technical points but it needs an extensive review by a native English speaker also for technical terms being used. ”
我感觉Reviewer 2 是行家,直接提问了一两个专业问题, 整体评价不仅专业而且友好,给了个“English language and style are fine/minor spell check required”。
重点是,Reviewer 1, 是个hanhan. 一看就是个外行, 不懂概念,把目标检测和目标跟踪混为一谈,挑不了专业,挑你写作问题。最haha的是这位大佬写的“comments” 里面一大堆写作错误(笑喷ing)。 最后给了我一个“I consider the paper acceptable after minor revision of the technical points but it needs an extensive review by a native English speaker also for technical terms being used. ”