意军吧 关注:2,549贴子:40,072

请问一下各位大佬,一战中,意大利军为啥没有能够攻入奥匈本土?

只看楼主收藏回复

请问一下各位大佬,
一战中,
意大利军为啥没有能够攻入奥匈本土?
是战术原因,还是实力不足🤔


来自Android客户端1楼2019-05-26 17:46回复
    看资料,意大利军队集结了90万军队以及1700门火炮,如果能做到突然袭击,阿尔卑斯山,伊松佐河总有一个能打下来的吧?或者还有没有其他方式可以打进去?😶


    来自Android客户端2楼2019-05-26 17:48
    回复
      2025-07-20 00:00:09
      广告
      维托里奥维内托战役不算是打进去了吗


      IP属地:广东3楼2019-05-26 19:24
      收起回复
        第一个奥军控制着伊松佐河上的所有渡口和几个重要高地,此外在托尔明诺和戈里齐亚有前沿阵地,在地形上占据优势。
        第二个就是意军自己的问题了,像步炮协调差,不熟悉阵地攻防战术,还有卡多纳自己在指挥方面上也犯了不少错误(这一点海明威在《永别了,武器》里曾经狠批过,说我们只有那个不中用的卡多纳),所以最后打了整整11次伊松佐河以后才终于看到了胜利的曙光(然而在卡波雷托马上就变成了彻底的悲哀)


        来自Android客户端4楼2019-05-28 01:49
        收起回复
          道理我都懂,但是一战和VV有什么关系


          IP属地:新疆来自Android客户端5楼2019-05-28 08:53
          收起回复
            天佑奥皇


            IP属地:河北来自Android客户端8楼2019-06-21 22:02
            回复
              山地惩罚-65%,跨河惩罚-50%
              经验-25%
              指挥官zz-20%


              IP属地:北京9楼2019-06-29 22:53
              收起回复
                卡多尔纳的“优秀”指挥,意大利军队缺少必要的火炮支援,奥地利军队准备充分。


                IP属地:陕西来自Android客户端10楼2019-07-05 07:04
                回复
                  2025-07-19 23:54:09
                  广告
                  第一是意军缺乏重炮,以下文字引用The Great War一书
                  The most common field guns were the 75 mm Krupp or Deport models, with a number of 65 mm mountain guns which could be broken down to be transported by mules in rough country. But again there were simply too few of them, while heavy artillery was also in scarce supply. The Italians had none of the high-trajectory mortars that were so essential in mountain warfare.


                  IP属地:浙江来自Android客户端11楼2019-07-30 17:49
                  回复
                    第二是奥军修建了大量的防御工事,做好了意大利入侵的准备。以下内容引自Battle in the Alps:A History of the Italian Front of the First World War
                    They worked frantically to construct defensive positions over terrain which was usually not suitable for digging trenches. Most often, gun pits and troop shelters had to be blasted into the solid rock, or stone and timber walls set up across stretches of literally solid ground. Trees had to be felled to create fields of fire. Barbed wire and defensive materials and weapons of all kinds had to be hauled to the crests of mountain ridges. And of course roads for supply had to be etched into the often sparsely-populated frontier areas. Later, when army commands had been set up, mechanical drilling and boring equipment became available. It was a godsend to the engineers attempting to hollow out bunkers, dig tunnels, and secure gun battery emplacements. Pneumatic drills driven by gasoline engines were the norm, but the heavier, faster drills and the tunnel-boring machines were sometimes fully gear-driven and were usually self-propelled; one model ran on a narrow-gauge railway. Visiting the front in August 1916, Lord Northcliffe observed a rock drill which was “unusually light and strong”, displaying a “new type of Mercedes engine”.


                    IP属地:浙江来自Android客户端12楼2019-07-30 17:57
                    回复
                      而且意军步炮协同差,通讯落后


                      IP属地:浙江来自Android客户端13楼2019-07-30 18:01
                      回复
                        伊松佐河战役


                        IP属地:甘肃来自Android客户端14楼2019-08-20 13:58
                        收起回复
                          意大利本身军费太穷了(特别是炮兵),加上卡尔多纳这个牛B的指挥官,伊松佐河战役打了11次都没染指奥军半寸土地


                          来自Android客户端15楼2019-08-23 01:03
                          回复
                            镇楼图有没有21世纪的


                            IP属地:英国来自Android客户端16楼2020-06-08 23:55
                            回复
                              2025-07-19 23:48:09
                              广告
                              德军实力1,法国2,英国3,俄国4,奥匈帝国5,意大利6,回答完毕。


                              来自Android客户端17楼2021-07-27 00:35
                              回复