advanced_english_i吧 关注:36贴子:194
  • 15回复贴,共1

145 第二单元批判性评论 10.18

只看楼主收藏回复

critical analysis


1楼2016-10-13 10:33回复
    Here pls upload your critical analysis on at least one aspect of the text (eg. author's way of writing, his/her view, other points etc) where you think is not able to stimulate your resonance or some parts whichmay not be convincing enough for you to follow.


    3楼2016-10-13 10:46
    回复


      IP属地:浙江14楼2016-10-15 19:36
      回复


        IP属地:浙江15楼2016-10-15 20:35
        回复


          IP属地:浙江16楼2016-10-16 11:39
          回复



            18楼2016-10-16 14:34
            收起回复


              19楼2016-10-16 14:40
              回复


                20楼2016-10-16 17:08
                回复
                  As a matter of fact, we cannot judge the author from our own perspective, as a native born Chinese. By the way, we also have no rights to criticize her. But we can imagine the cultural background and the western idea the author has accepted, which must have influenced the author. I quite agree with the idea of Monica that "the author physically receives some Chinese language but she doesn't accept it mentally.
                  It's typically of her to be white-washed, which is a group of people feel the white are more advanced so that they want to get rid of the Asian appearance. The root cause of the phenomenon is the first language those ABC have learned, and the result is that recognition of their root culture is reducing.
                  Though she and her brother consider the Chinese culture abhorrent, we cannot criticize it because that's caused by the background. The only thing we can say is that the attitude they towards his family. Though it's widely acknowledged that western culture is famous for freedom, the author is lacking in the basic respect for her family.
                  Jessica 孙


                  来自iPhone客户端21楼2016-10-16 18:57
                  回复


                    来自iPhone客户端25楼2016-10-17 09:41
                    回复

                      by Alice Cai


                      26楼2016-10-18 12:35
                      回复
                        After reading the passage, I can thoroughly feel the author's deep hate of Chinese culture, which makes me annoyed. This whole passage is filled with the author's unsatisfaction and disgust about Chinese culture. To my perspective, even if we do not like a kind of culture, we cannot express it out in such a direct way for it may make us rude and be easily criticized by others. What's more, it will hurt the feeling of Chinese-cultivated people. Perhaps the force of learning Chinese given by her mother makes her mad about Chinese, but in my opinion, one should try to love what he or she learns so that one can acquire the best quintessence of a certain kind of knowledge.
                        ——Julia 杨


                        27楼2016-10-18 21:38
                        回复


                          29楼2016-10-18 23:57
                          回复


                            30楼2016-10-19 13:03
                            回复