时光之轮吧 关注:5,697贴子:63,774
  • 22回复贴,共1

亚斯莫丁被谁杀死的

只看楼主收藏回复



IP属地:山西1楼2014-05-11 13:48回复
    同求


    2楼2014-05-11 22:26
    回复
      事先申明,亚斯莫丁已没有复活的可能性了,他本人在天空之火中死亡。莫瑞笛(伊君)并没有绑架他。首先,乔丹将时轮这个系列看得太严肃以至于他本人没有使用双关语。(take,death)第二,乔丹自己在一次采访中说到 亚斯莫丁已死,他说到,亚君就像是一只打算过马路的小猫,不过它没有成功。“所以他不会回来了?”(采访者)“是的,他不会回来了”RJ回答。第三,在另一次采访中他又回答道,他本人否定了其他关于亚君失踪的理论。


      IP属地:英国3楼2014-05-11 22:38
      回复
        Now that that's out of the way, let's get on to serious discussion. First, we will consider what the general requirements are for Asmodean's murderer. Second, we will round up all the usual suspects (and some unusual ones). Then, we will examine all the general requirements in detail, and see if we can draw any conclusions from them. Next, we will eliminate suspects who couldn't possibly have done it, and those who theoretically could have done it, but who probably didn't. Finally, we will examine the cases for and against the remaining suspects.


        IP属地:英国4楼2014-05-11 22:42
        回复
          Suspects (overly-complete list):
          Aran'gar or Osan'gar
          Demandred
          Graendal
          Ishamael/Moridin
          Lanfear
          Mesaana
          Moghedien
          Moiraine
          Padan Fain
          Sammael
          Semirhage
          Shaidar Haran
          Slayer
          Taim


          IP属地:英国5楼2014-05-11 22:43
          回复
            Hardly any of this is terribly conclusive, because there is very little information to work with. It seems, though, that the most likely candidate for Slayer's employer is Lanfear


            IP属地:英国6楼2014-05-11 22:45
            回复
              国外时轮FAQ中分析了一大段,总结是兰菲儿,但目前为止木有官方确认


              IP属地:英国来自Android客户端7楼2014-05-11 22:46
              收起回复
                你够了。话说对此我有个很有意思的推测,我记得它的上一章节似乎叫“烧毁的丝线”还是什么,我们都知道烈火会烧断丝线,而在此之前兰德正好“丧心病狂”(为了表达用尽全力的意思)的使用了烈火,杀死了那个我没记住他名字的人…这样的话会烧断多长的丝线,会使怎样的历史倒退。并且在亚莫斯丁死之前也表惊讶的问道:怎么是你?如果杀他的人是将他送给兰德当经验的兰飞儿,那么他为什么会这么惊讶?他似乎早就觉得兰飞儿会杀他。差不多就是这样的意思,应该是那个被我忘记姓名之人之前杀的一人,被历史倒退而复活,过来把亚做掉了。


                IP属地:北京来自手机贴吧9楼2014-05-12 21:00
                收起回复
                  seriously. hint after hint after hint, and finally Brandon Sanderson (the light illuminate his soul) gives TWO more hints in this book, and then says it in the glossary in fairly plain language, and people are still trying to suggest that it was NOT Graendal.
                  It has been said, in VERY plain language that the answer was intuitively obvious, and that hints were added in later volumes. only 5 people in the entire history of the discussion of this topic have been accepted as possible candidates for "intuitively obvious" and EVERYONE BUT GRAENDAL is eliminated when you factor in future hints.
                  it was Graendal
                  she acted alone
                  there was no second gunman
                  Graendal killed Asmodean...with a MAGIC BULLET


                  IP属地:英国10楼2014-05-12 21:12
                  回复
                    在theoryland中貌似很多人同意是大胸妹杀的


                    IP属地:英国来自Android客户端11楼2014-05-12 21:15
                    回复
                      招呼@10293817 @祭坛上的乌鸦


                      IP属地:英国来自Android客户端12楼2014-05-12 21:21
                      回复
                        要知道的是亚肯定不会对任何一个除了已知死亡以外的弃光魔使杀他表示惊讶的,一定是已知死亡的,然后已不可思议的事情复活的。要不,难道会是小伊…


                        IP属地:北京来自手机贴吧13楼2014-05-12 21:22
                        回复
                          亚斯莫丁之死 来自theory land
                          毫无疑问是古兰黛干的.
                          亚斯莫丁死之前已有好几位使徒死了(一卷两位和雷纹?还有lanfear, 伊沙梅尔), 蜘蛛在乡贤手上.
                          所以只有古兰黛, 沙马奥, 色墨海格,狄芒德还有麦煞那有可能性.
                          以上五位中只有沙马奥和古兰黛知道亚斯莫丁加入兰德一方.
                          在 “ 天空之火” the first spark章中, 蓝菲尔, 雷纹, 沙马奥, 古兰黛有一次会议提到了亚斯莫丁.
                          我(作者)不认为有不会引导的人会让一位使徒恐惧, 所以是会引导的人, 亚斯莫丁又和黑宗没有联系.所以只有可能是其他使徒杀了他.这里提到了银色,所以有极大可能是一位女性使徒.
                          既然古兰黛和雷纹有约定,她可能会在雷纹死后做出反应.
                          古兰黛知道亚斯莫丁的现况(与兰德的关系), 所以她去凯姆林还是为了杀死亚斯莫丁.
                          “Idly--but with a shiver, too--he wondered whether being reborn in this fashion made him a new man”


                          IP属地:英国14楼2014-05-12 21:50
                          收起回复
                            以上也有很多问题


                            IP属地:英国来自Android客户端15楼2014-05-12 21:51
                            回复
                              最先在十二卷附录里确定的,已经没有疑问了
                              就是古兰黛


                              来自手机贴吧16楼2014-05-12 22:20
                              收起回复